What do you think...

I would like an opinion.  The below two pictures show an existing set of treatments and then the piece made in the same style for an adjacent room.

This is the living room.

This is the new treatment in the Dining Room.

 How well do you feel the workroom scaled and manufactured the piece to match.  And while we are at it what do you think about the piece?  Would you have preferred an arched shape, and would you have like the sheer (it is a sheer) to be unlined?